We do not know how to disagree.

30-Second Version For Busy People

This past week, we were starkly reminded of the darkness around us and what potentially exists next door or even in our own hearts. We preach the loss of unity, but a democracy thrives on diversity. We don't lack unity; we have simply forgotten how to disagree.

  • Better thought: Better relationships lead to better disagreements.

  • Better action: Extend a hand across the aisle rather than planting the seeds of hatred and division.

When Christians get better, everyone gets better. Right now, the world needs better Christians.

Full Version

The recent assassination attempt on President Trump at a Pennsylvania rally has left many in shock. Perhaps you are exhausted from the continual conversation about it, this newsletter notwithstanding.

But we cannot shy away from the conversation despite the insanity that is found online, in the world, and in our own broken minds. The attempted assassination of a former president is a very real reminder of this present darkness that exists all around us and entirely inside us.

One of my main takeaways from this terrible moment in American history is not our loss of unity—true democracy thrives on diversity and debate—but our loss of disagreement.

We need to be better at disagreeing with one another rather than trying to impose agreement. We have become obsessed with unity (nationalism, climate change, etc.). The mentality has become that you are my enemy if you oppose my position.

As Christians, we need to develop better thoughts and actions regarding the lost art of disagreement because (as Christians) mostpeople will oppose our worldview.

So, how can we be better at disagreeing?

Let your conversation be always full of grace, seasoned with salt, so that you may know how to answer everyone.

Colossians 4:6

BETTER THOUGHT

Photo by Adrian Swancar / Unsplash

Today's better thought: Better relationships lead to better disagreements.

Professional hostage negotiators, police interviewers, therapists, mediators, and diplomats truly understand this idea. They master the "conversation under the conversation," excelling at postponing the substance of a disagreement while nurturing the relationship. They do this because they recognize how much relationships matter.

As a pastor, I have ongoing conversations about issues people often ignore: how we should speak, where our priorities should lie, the proper order of significant life events, and the searing doubts of faith and eternity.

I've learned not to expect from people what was never put into them. The world (our friends, family, neighbors, and co-workers) doesn't know any better because they haven’t been shown any better.

Instead, I've started focusing on the relationship first. I will invest in the lives of people I want to have any influence over—not simply to one day show them their faults, but to learn from them as I hope they learn from me.

Disagreeing well is a lost art, but we can recover it. I'm not always the best at it. I avoid conflict as if it will curl under my toenails and rot. So, I focus instead on relationships. I think that's a better starting place, anyway.

If you're looking for a book about disagreement or conflict, here are a few recommendations (in no particular order):

A gentle answer turns away wrath, but a harsh word stirs up anger.

Proverbs 15:1

BETTER ACTION

Empty Chairs

Photo by Ricardo Arce / Unsplash

Today's better action: Reach across the aisle and grasp hands with another human.

American political commentator, former attorney, and self-proclaimed follower of Jesus, David French, issued a challenge to listeners of The Dispatch podcast in his reflection on the assassination attempt on Donald Trump:

“It feels like what's happening with each new incident is we're planting the seed of hatred for the next incident in the way we respond to each other. . . If you have a Trump-supporting friend or neighbor, you should reach out to them and say. . . You must be grieving. We are all grieving. You must be angry. I'm angry along with you that this happened. That is a gesture of humanity to say this was evil, full stop, and save the politics for later.”

David French on The Dispatch Podcast

I took this challenge to heart. Although I'm not a fan of Trump as our country's leader, I do know people who are, and I sent them a message to grieve with them.

What does this challenge look like for you? Who on the other side of the aisle can you reach your hand across and, by gesture, say, "We might disagree, but we can still be in a relationship"?

I witnessed this kind of conversation last Thursday. Two people disagreed on a matter of church worship. They came to different conclusions and understood Scripture differently. They didn't agree to disagree but instead acknowledged their different conclusions and maintained their relationship.

In times of deep division, reaching out to someone with a different perspective and offering genuine compassion can be a powerful act of faith. It reminds us that our common humanity is greater than our political or ideological differences.

Let's plant better seeds.

BECOMING A BETTER CHRISTIAN

When Christians get better, everyone gets better. Here are a few ways I am getting better this week.

Hit "reply" and let me know what you're doing!

Trivia — Something I Wish I Said

Here is a quote that got me thinking this week. Who do you think said it?

“There is some good in this world, and it’s worth fighting for.”

Login or Subscribe to participate in polls.

Hit "reply" and let me know what you're thinking.

Reply

or to participate.